| Candace Cameron Bure (Aurora Teagarden) |
| Niall Matter (Nick Miller) |
| Marilu Henner (Aida Teagarden) |
| Lexa Doig (Sally Allison) |
| Peter Benson (Le Det. Arthur Smith) |
| Miranda Frigon (Lynn Liggett-Smith) |
| Dylan Sloane (Phillip Pifer) |
| Ellie Harvie (Lillian Tibbett) |
| Cole Vigue (Davis Mettle) |
| Brad Harder (L'officier Heard) |
| Ecstasia Sanders (Amanda Gaines) |
| Matthew Kevin Anderson (David Kotkin) |
| Rhiannon Fish (Melissa Needham) |
| Adam Beauchesne (Hal Needham) |
| Billy Wickman (Tony Gulati) |
| Sarah-Jane Redmond (Bianca Avery) |
| David Lewis (Ben Avery) |
| Yoshié Bancroft (Misty Wagner) |
| Ross Wallace (Raymond Wagner) |